WIP - Fanshen

Eridah's picture

 

Just doing some concept studies for Fanshen, who I eventually want to model in Zbrush. This is a high value underpainting (half greyscale, darkest 50 gray) which I'll eventually be painting into in photoshop with simulated glazes. Going for something more painterly than the last, with no predrawing. Just blocked the basic shapes in value and then refined them. Thanks for any comments, critique always welcome. Images below cut.

Heulwen's picture

(( Wow, I love the dress

((

Wow, I love the dress already.........and think it's amazing you can build this via lights and darks with no drawing.  My brain cannot comprehend how, but it appreciates the outcome!  Can't wait to see more as you develop it  :)

))

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"(I) know what art is! It's paintings of horses!"

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Charisma's picture

((Like Heulwen, my brain

((Like Heulwen, my brain cannot wrap around how you can do such wonderful work without a predrawing. Just blocking in and going with it seems so much a hassle, but you make it look so lovely. The dress is beautiful, but her expression is especially fetching.))

---------------------------------

She smells of the sun
And she's constantly saying
That's it's alright because lies sound so nice
And like soil to seed goes, casting my fears aside

-Satellite, BT

---------------------------------

She smells of the sun
And she's constantly saying
That's it's alright because lies sound so nice
And like soil to seed goes, casting my fears aside

-Satellite, BT

Alenei's picture

 Interesting. Way cool,

 Interesting. Way cool, too.

 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


I'm a Twit now! Wait a second....

 

Pepsi is for mages.

- Dominic Hobbs

Berrianna's picture

 ((Okay, nobody else has

 ((Okay, nobody else has said it, so I will.

Hey...nice Fanny...

:) ))

Aldred's picture

Oh dearest Fanny!  As

Oh dearest Fanny!  As beautiful as ever!

(( Wonderful!  I can't wait to see more of it! ))

Celise's picture

(( Wow awesome

((

Wow awesome stuff!

))

------------------------------------------

"I want to hurt you just to hear you screaming my name..." - Tarja -

"People will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel." - Maya Angelou -

Eridah's picture

Thanks for all the kind

Thanks for all the kind words folks. I'll be getting back to this soon enough. Been working on the other workshop project. Also, feel free to critique. You see something that doesn't look right to you, speak up. Your don't have to be an artist to see something wrong. So if something feels off, say something. That's why it's a Work In Progress thread. Appreciate your time!

Yours,

Eri

Eridah's picture

Slight pose change, adding

Slight pose change, adding more twist to the look back. Facial work. Proportions work on the arm.

Ineesa's picture

 The face and pose looks

 The face and pose looks great, Eri!  A few little details on her shoulder are making it appear a bit square, and also her hair seems a bit "high" - sort of like her forehead is already the upper half of her head, then her hair is setting on top of that, like a poofy wig!  Smush that poof down, unless it really is a Southern Belle bouffant!

 

 


 Sigs.jpg

Eridah's picture

There was something a

There was something a little too "young" about the first take of the face. So I did a two value repaint to get something a bit more adult and classical. I also pushed the turn a bit more. I'm showing this closeup, because it reads better. I work these things at a much higher res than I show as a rule. Also, dropping back to these solid values helps me not cheat with all the blending. I was getting ahead of myself there. Also, I did hit Neetie's crits.  Thanks Neetie!

Verisimi's picture

((So wonderful to see this.

((So wonderful to see this. I'm really enjoying this, Eri!))

Eridah's picture

Today's update. Working on

Today's update. Working on the ground, the dress, the arm and torso. Playing with some compositional ideas and lighting implications. Critique welcomed and appreciated.

Aktarin's picture

Visually, I feel it might

Visually, I feel it might add something to bring her arm a little more to the right of the composition, displaying more of her bare back and twisting her waist a bit. Just moving that shoulder over and broadening the visible back would make her head pose almost coquettish or inviting, and given the dress, that almost seems par for the course. Just my 2 cents. Good cloth work.. wish I could handle fabrics the way you do XD.

Eridah's picture

Ok finally got a free hour

Ok finally got a free hour to work on this, turned the shoulder back a bit per Aktarin's comment. Chopped the frame on the painting behind her down a bit. Was getting crazy there. C & C welcomed.

Eridah's picture

Ok, I'm still working this

Ok, I'm still working this in high value, but I was getting eye strain looking at it in half grey so I ran the levels down to get a full range. Working on blending the values in the body now, lots of work on the scene itself. Work on the painting and it's frame, the table, etc. Critique is always welcome. Remember that nothing will be as black as this is at the moment. I'll be working the darks later with color on top of the grey under painting. This is just so that I can see what's happening in a full scale as opposed to the half I've been working with.

Ineesa's picture

 I still think her

 I still think her forehead/head is too tall =O

The background is nice.  Would that much of her back/shoulders be showing in the mirror?

 

 


 Sigs.jpg

Eridah's picture

Not sure on the forehead,

Not sure on the forehead, but I'll look at it again. As to the mirror, likely not. It's really roughed in, I think she'd be more frame right it in.

Heulwen's picture

The bit that looks slightly

The bit that looks slightly 'off' to me is her......deltoid?  Um, the connection between her shoulder neck and head.  It seems to rise very high in a very steep way.  Also the alignment of her neck, as it were.  She looks slightly like she's sticking her neck out, turtle-fashion, and I always kinda imagined Fanny being ramrod straight!  The apparent 'height' of the (? deltoid ?) is what gets me most, though.  However what I don't know is whether this is a 'trick' on my vision played by the part of the values hiding where the 'lines' will be, or if it's really the angle it seems to be.  I'm guessing it's a trick, and the only real problem is I don't know how to 'see' in values properly  :)

Hope that makes sense, but I doubt it  ;)

Loving watching the process!

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"(I) know what art is! It's paintings of horses!"

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Eridah's picture

Ayep, you're right. The

Ayep, you're right. The delt does look squished and the trapezius might be extending a bit high. As for the neck, I'm not sure straight up and down is what I want. The spine does this "S" curve front to back from hips to ribcage then back at the neck. That feels right to me. Don't worry about your ability to see "values" though. You can see like anyone else. You see something that feels off, say something like you just did. It's all helpful.

Heulwen's picture

Trapezius!  That's what I

Trapezius!  That's what I meant about the bit that seemed a bit high and steep.......I fail at anatomy, that's what I get for being too lazy to even Google before replying  ;)

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"(I) know what art is! It's paintings of horses!"

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Kharris's picture

The neck/shoulder bothers

The neck/shoulder bothers me quite a bit too. And she seems to have a very weak jaw to me... I dunno. I'm not very articulate, but that whole area just sits ... "wrong" with me.  Sorry I'm not more help. :(

Eridah's picture

Finally got some time to

Finally got some time to get back to this. Hopefully hitting the notes from last time. Work on the dress and around the body overall.

 

Heulwen's picture

Going well!  She looks

Going well!  She looks almost.........Munchy   :)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"(I) know what art is! It's paintings of horses!"

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hakkajin's picture

Holy wrinkles, batman

Holy wrinkles, batman

Eridah's picture

Back to this after a long

Back to this after a long hiatus. Brought it over to Artrage for a bit more painterly control.

Scartaris's picture

comments from a doorknob

((

Her right cheekbone seems really low, and her shoulders seem narrow (which is to say, the distance from her right shoulder to her left shoulder seems disproportionately small). It may just be the lighting. And there is something vaguely Escher-like about the table legs, but I am not sure what it is.

))

--
With all its sham, drudgery, and broken dreams,
it is still a beautiful world.

Eridah's picture

(( Cheekbone, image right?

((

Cheekbone, image right? Or her right? If it's her right (image left), I think I agree with you. As for the distance between the shoulders, she's twisted so they're almost in profile, but now I'm looking for something for reference to see if I've gotten it right. The table... I think I might see it, but if you can describe in more detail what you feel is off, it would go a long way to helping me fix it. Looking at it now, I think I see a bit too much curve in the bottom of the vase and I would say the table leg nearest her needs some work on it's curve and angle in relation to its compatriot on the other side. Seems like it's curve is higher than the other.

))

Heulwen's picture

(( I love how it's easier

((

I love how it's easier to pick at other people's superior work than try to draw anything myself, so here goes  ;)   Agree on the vase, the 'ellipse' of the base is too circular......the ellipse that marks the mouth of the vase looks much better though I think.  So maybe if they matched in shape?

I think the oval mirror is also not quite at the right angle to maintain the perspective....it doesn't look 'flat' on the wall, if you know what I mean.  If the two scrolly bits make a horizontal line, then that line doesn't match the line of the skirting board.

The table......I'm with Scar, but saying what it is exactly that gives that impression is much harder!  I *think*' we're perhaps seeing too much of the surface, width-wise?  Once the vase ellipse is fixed, that might suggest a different angle on the table top?  Maybe.  And I'm not sure the two legs match in terms of where they're attached to the underside.  Um.  Something like that  >.> 

Perspective is sucky-hard @.@

Looking good though, overall!

 

))

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"(I) know what art is! It's paintings of horses!"

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Artisania's picture

 "Perspective is

 "Perspective is sucky-hard @.@"

That's what the book is for.  >:|

 ;)

____________________

Just call me Artie, dear.

 

Just call me Artie, dear.


Sigs.jpg

Kharris's picture

I think the bottom of her

I think the bottom of her skirt might be causing some of this too, with the vase... I agree about the mirror, and I agree about the shoulders looking wrong. Like you so often tell Artie, the sihlouette seems off...

 

I really love what you've done though. :D This is coming along great. I'm floored by how lovely your values are. As a line art kind of person, this stuff always stuns me. Anyone that can shade... you are my gods.

Scartaris's picture

cheekbones and table legs

((

Image-left cheekbone.

As for the table, I looked very closely to try and figure out what it is that seems off. I am not sure I found it, but one thing is that the foot of the image-left table seems much closer to the edge of the wall than the top of the image-left table leg. Do you know what I mean?

I like the dress and her posture and the mirror. I do see the thing about the bottom of the mirror not being parallel to the floor, now that it has been pointed out.

))

--
With all its sham, drudgery, and broken dreams,
it is still a beautiful world.

Artisania's picture

The thing I see about the

The thing I see about the table legs comes from my brain (at least) being used to such table legs as having their "outward hump" on the corner, as seen with this table:

Fanny's table seems to have the legs humping out only to the side, and they're also like... coming out from under the table-top.  I don't know a lot of tables of that style that are put together that way, since the hump-out of the legs is a decorative thing and usually put out on the corners and not hidden under a tabletop. 

I find the perspective over all a little "high" in regards to the viewpoint, and I'm not sure if it needs to be that high for how we're looking at Fanny. I'd have to put it in my computer and play with it myself to see.  The angle of the floor just seems pretty dramatic, which in turn affects the table, etc.

Her near cheekbone does look a little low compared to the far one.  I think if you took the eyeline and lowered it a smidge or two as a guide, it would show the near cheek's "droop".

/nitpicks for breakfast!

 

 

____________________

Just call me Artie, dear.

 

Just call me Artie, dear.


Sigs.jpg

Artisania's picture

Lolz perspective is a

Lolz perspective is a bitch.

Red lines are what's there, green lines are my uh, "corrections"

Click for bigger 'cause it's really big.

The issue with the table (and less noticably the picture frame) is that it's going to a different vanishing point than the wall.  If the picture continued, the table would actually intercept the wall, sliding into it in a way.  If you pull it out to the same vanishing point as the wall (as defined by the convergence of the footboard, which seems fine when looking at it) then the table will sit more correctly.

Also, the far leg is back a bit farther than the near leg.  I think that was just a matter of like, unconciously wanting to show that claw foot even though it might get partly covered by the dress.

I didn't mess with the oval picture or the vase because ovals r hard in perspective.

I think this would also help in the viewpoint seeming so "high" - we're seeing a bit too much of the tabletop right now, methinks.

I hope that helps!

 

____________________

Just call me Artie, dear.

 

Just call me Artie, dear.


Sigs.jpg

Heulwen's picture

Whoa, cool, it's like one

Whoa, cool, it's like one of those diagrams to see where all the shots came from in a room full of slaughtered gangsters  :)

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"(I) know what art is! It's paintings of horses!"

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Eridah's picture

Ack! You've caught me in a

Ack! You've caught me in a cardinal violation of the perspective rules! That'll teach me just to eyeball it and call it good enough. I think you're spot on here Artie.

Zyjiin's picture

((Keep up on this one! I

((Keep up on this one! I just noticed it now, and the progress I see as I scan down is very distinct. How many hours have you put into this? I still remember reading some of your early work about Fanshen back in the day. I can't add any more criticism then the great notes that have already been given, so I just want to add that I love the faint outline of light in the mirror. Such a small detail, but it brings that image of the image to life. Well done!))

 

––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

Azumah, Ranharr, Sydallus, Sherrard, Reedlebix, Grishma, and Tibbins


Eridah's picture

(( To be honest, I don't

((

To be honest, I don't keep very close track of the time I spend on a piece. I'm slow as a rule. So double or triple what a good artist would take ;) Seriously though, I tend to work in sessions of about two to three hours at a time and the amount of revisions you folks get to see is maybe half to a third of the sessions I've done. So ball park maybe 24 work hours on this so far? Which sounds like too few so maybe 1.5 to 2 times that again for scratching my head and throwing things out. It's one of the reasons I can't really think about charging for commissions. The amount of time I put into a piece is NEVER going to be paid for in something like a character comission. It's just not going to happen unless I value my time really really low, which I don't. Time is really more important than money to me, with all the things I want to do with it.

By the way, it's great to see you still about Zyjiin! Hope you're enjoying Haven and making contact for RP in game.

Yours,

Eri

P.S. Xistla says you need to get some Gnome Crunchies for the guild hall. ;)

))

Eridah's picture

Long time no update.

Long time no update. Hitting Artie's notes, so a lot of repainting & painting out in progress here. Vase will come back once I get the table more established. Shortened the neck a bit, and did a total repaint of that area. Big change to the hair style, going for a more aristocratic coiffed look. Hair curlers anyone? Moved the cheek bone up, need to do a bit of softening there. Moved the jaw down and back a bit, and did some work on anatomy there, defining the massetter. Still not happy with the shoulder girdle and the clavicle. This angle is weird on them and it's hard to visualize what they would look like and how they'd catch the light. I might have to break down on have someone pose for me, just so I can stop fussing with it. As always, all comments are welcome.

Eridah's picture

Not so long an update.

Not so long an update. Lots more work on the neck, back and shoulder. Some anatomy work on the forearm. Refined the table shape and got a shadow started under it. More tweaks to the hair, lowering it down just a bit so it doesn't look quite so Maire-Antoinette.

Scartaris's picture

Something weird

Tavlo's picture

 I just noticed her shadow

 I just noticed her shadow on the wall and liiiiiiike it

But I agree with Scar that something is happening to her head and neck that is weird.  Her shoulders look great.  The neck is looking a little long and narrow (I know you like your long necks!) and there's something odd about the way the head is.  Or it could just be the neck.

There is a plane between the eye and the hairline on the side of her face that right now looks to be coming out, as if she has a brow ridge that comes down and encircles her eye.  It bothers me!!!

Hair looks awesome. Clumpy clumpy!

 

_________________________

And I wrap my fear around me like a blanket...

 

And I wrap my fear around me like a blanket...

 

Sigs.jpg

Heulwen's picture

I am also of this

I am also of this camp. 

Looking at some pictures online suggets that turning the head like that and being viewed from this sort of angle creates the impression of the neck being shorter, no matter what size you may *know* it is mathematically/anatomically.  Or even the chin 'dropping' as well, depending on how relaxed the person is.  I think in your very FIRST picture of Fanny in this whole thread, you have a more natural neck proportion for the viewing-angle of this pose. 

Also, that neck tendon would look as prominant as you have it on her 'stretched' (far) side but not, I think, on the 'compressed' (close) side of the neck.  Even on a very stiff and formal model (like this Getty Images one here) that side of the neck is still 'compressed' (I don't know what else to call it) and the tendon doesn't bulge like that, until such a point the head is turned so far it starts to 'appear' at the bottom again (like this one here).

I'm glad you're still having time to work on this, it's a lot of fun to follow along with and fling uninformed bits of shell at you from the peanut gallery  ;)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"(I) know what art is! It's paintings of horses!"

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Eridah's picture

Hum, ayep I agree the neck

Hum, ayep I agree the neck is too long. Looks like another chop and drop. Lifting her hair showed up this error in proportion (and my predeliction for lengthening necks). As for the brow ridge, it's likely that I've too much white there, popping that out. Some reshaping of that darker shape behind it should fix the problem. What's bothering me at the moment, and I think Scar as well,  is the dark shadow under the jaw. It's making the face look like it's pushing back farther into the neck I think. That area's going to need a lot of work. Unfortunately, busy again at work. *sigh*

Tavlo's picture

 I'm going to make a

 I'm going to make a Radical Suggestion for when you're no longer so busy at work.

Make a new layer.  On it, cover her face with a fresh layer of paint.  Entirely.  Like she just has an egg-head with the forehead and chin limits set.  Then draw over that all your usual guidelines for features and basically do the face over from scratch with a concentration on the various planes and shading, and then on the details.  Basically give her a whole new "fresh" face.

I say that because often times when a drawing gets to this point, and it's still looking mysteriously "off", it's not something that can be fixed by poking and prodding at little things because something underneath, in the basic structure, has gotten "off".  You may be right about the shadow under the chin (I'm not sure about that, I'm just waking up @_@) but I actually think seeing the head as a "blank" would help with that as well (I think maybe she needs some skin-loosening behind her jaw... I dunno, I haven't looked at Heulwen's references yet either).  But anyway, I wouldn't marry that face, but rather try a fresh one, and see if that helps bring it together.

The neck looks MUUUUCH better!

 Oh and I meant to comment under your last post.  Need coffee....

_________________________

And I wrap my fear around me like a blanket...

 

And I wrap my fear around me like a blanket...

 

Sigs.jpg

Zyjiin's picture

  (( Still looks awesome.

 

(( Still looks awesome. Can't wait until you feel you've finished it.

 

Oh, and the Gnome Crunchies are in the pantry. Caramel flavor! ))

 

 I'd Rather Be Fishing. . .

 

––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

Azumah, Ranharr, Sydallus, Sherrard, Reedlebix, Grishma, and Tibbins


Eridah's picture

Ok, stole a few moments from

Ok, stole a few moments from the employer this morning to get at this while the comments were fresh in my mind. Hit the notes, I think. Need to work some highlight back into the neck, as that it's gotten a bit uniform in the process of reworking. The images were very helpful H'. Don't ever depreciate your comments. They're generally very insightful. Thanks to the rest of you for the comments. Always appreciated. Hopefully get some more time on this today.

Tavlo's picture

 Looking at the face again

 Looking at the face again here, these are just two things I'm spotting:

Her right eye is way too far over, too close to her hairline.  There's no room for the temple area.  It's also too "sunk" in.  Likewise, her mouth is too far back from her nose, like the centerline is curving back in too much, giving her an overbite issue, or not enough "chin" - and the chin bit may help with the appearance of her turned head.  So like, those two things, being that they are deeply structural, I'd suggest as above doing a repaint with sketching and guidelines, and sort of... .get her features back on track. 

Sorry to be so picky.  Taking figure drawing this semester so it's been all STRUCTURE STRUCTURE STRUCTURE PLANES PLANES PLANES.  @_@

 

_________________________

And I wrap my fear around me like a blanket...

 

And I wrap my fear around me like a blanket...

 

Sigs.jpg

Eridah's picture

Took this home last night

Took this home last night and repainted the face (four times before I got something I liked). Got some tilt into the head which I think helps the gesture of the look. May need to look at the highlights on the hair so that there's no cue's left over that counter that tilt. Took care of the chin falling back making her all "English". Maybe needs a bit more contrast in the face yet, though this is an underpaint so that might be taken care of when the color comes in eventually. Will give myself a few days on it before I touch that part again to get fresh eyes. Again, all comments and observations welcomed.

P.S. Not sure I like this after all.... *sigh* back to the drawing board. Oh gods, punage too.

Eridah's picture

And five tries later again...

And five tries later again...

Eridah's picture

Trash it, do over, trash it,

fanny17.jpg

Trash it, do over, trash it, do over. Closer to what I want...

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.